I went to a faith symposium on Saturday and walked away with my mind spinning from challenging thoughts. As the information has begun to settle, I keep coming back to one thought:
We
have forgotten how to disagree.
I’m
not a fan of cliches, but the words “agree to disagree” keep coming to mind,
and while in most instances I know that I can do this, even I, with sixteen
years of therapy and countless hours of intentional work to be open to ways and
people who differ from me, struggle to make this sentiment a reality.
It’s
human nature to want to be “right.” But what if “right” can’t be agreed upon?
There
are always two dichotomies, opposites, or extremes of every belief or situation:
right vs. wrong; left vs. right; introvert vs. extravert; hard vs. soft; loud
vs. soft; fast vs. slow; black vs. white; life vs. death; heaven vs. hell; good
vs. evil; love vs. hate; you get the point.
Yet
in between those two opposites, there is always more…and that more is where
most of life is lived. Most of life doesn’t fall in the extremes, but rather
life falls on the sliding scale in between—and that scale moves back and forth
at different times in life, with different issues and different experiences—and
it’s different for different people.
For
instance, “love your neighbor” is a somewhat universal truth. But how we go
about doing that differs from person to person, community to community,
religion to religion. For some, love is the direct action of feeding the
hungry, clothing the poor, and providing shelter for the homeless. For others,
love is the indirect action of creating policies that promote law and order. For
some, love is giving people second chances over and over again. For others,
love is creating boundaries that say no. For some, love is embracing all people
in this life because Christ said that in Him there is no division. For others,
love is trying to save souls from hell because they don’t want anyone to suffer
an eternity separated from God.
Yesterday
in church, something was either said or sung about unity. My lingering thoughts
from the symposium on how we no longer know how to disagree crashed into the
command for unity and I realized something: Unity isn’t about everyone having
the same thoughts and beliefs. Unity is about accepting our differences and
doing our part and believing that God, somehow, can take all of the parts and
use them for good. Unity is about fighting for Love and being open to love and
believing that everyone is God’s beloved child—even if we don’t like them or
understand them because they don’t look like us, act like us, or come from the
same culture or background as us.
These
days, it seems like we are quick to judge, dismiss, unfriend, tell on, or cut-off
those who don’t agree with us after just one encounter. Don’t get me wrong. I
don’t think that we need to stick around people who are demeaning and abusive. Sometimes,
when the other person is coming from a place of hate, we should let go and move
on for our own personal safety and sanity. Sometimes, when the other person is
coming from a place of hate, we should speak our truth in love and then let
them be. Responding to hate with hate perpetuates hate. Responding to hate with
healthy love changes the world. But I digress.
I
just think that, in general, especially if we are Christians who profess to
follow a Christ who hung out with the marginalized of society, then we need to
know how to have conversations with people who are different than us and to be
open to what they have to say. I think that, in general, we need to learn to trust
the positive intent of people’s hearts rather than automatically deeming them “bad”
or “wrong” or “demonic” or “liberal” or “conservative” because of our own fears
and insecurities.
Like
I said earlier, even after years of therapy and intentional work to be open to
ways and people who differ from me, I still struggle. But I am trying. And I
invite you to try with me. Because, friends, God is so much bigger than we
allow God to be. And I think we may all be surprised by the people whom Jesus
loves.
Amen.